Do I Like the Book? Shrug.


When I went to the TEA protest in Sacramento, on one of the signs was written “Who is John Galt?” This is a reference to Ayn Rand’s magnum opus of “Objectivism,” Atlas Shrugged. aynrand

Rand, (1905-1982) grew up in the Soviet Union before emigrating to the U.S. Having seen the Before and After pictures of her beloved country in the advent of Bolshevism, she was greatly dismayed to see much sympathy in this country for the very same Socialist/Communist ideals she’d barely managed to escape. So she wrote long, overwrought, fervent treatises against this, thinly disguised as novels.

Atlas Shrugged has basically the same plot as her previous books, which is that a few sane, rational human beings exist against the machinations of totalitarian policies directed to discourage all initiative, poison productivity and crush basic freedoms.

atlassmallerNow that I’ve just reread it, I find the protagonists laughingly emotionally and intellectually stunted. Example: “Man’s motive power is his moral code.” Gag. The heroes reject any authority but their own and live for their accomplishments. Their rallying cry: “I swear - by my life and my love of it - that I will never live for the sake of another man, nor ask another man to live for mine.” Yet, somehow, they have no trouble devoting their lives for others they deem worthy. As you may have guessed, John Galt is the Christ figure in this piece. Are all novels written by staunch atheists this worshipful?

I’m pretty sure the book wouldn’t have gathered a following on the force of what it advocates, per se. It’s the fascinating progression of the bad guys in their rise to power and how their persuasion begets ideas ...
that give birth to guidelines...
that grow into directives..
that obliterate freedom and ruin the whole world. She demonstrates, with laser-sharpness, how compulsion to “give to the greater good” results in hatred toward one’s fellow man; how the policy of taking from the haves to give to the have-nots creates more of the needy, how only rewarding the collective guarantees that no one will ever show initiative, how eliminating competition drives production straight into the ground.

According to Rand, a government that promises to meet all the needs of its citizens ends up valuing none of them.

Whether you love or hate her books, one thing’s for certain: She’s spinning like a top in her grave right now. She’d have much to say about the renewed power of the unions in this country; the government’s moves toward nationalized banks, industries and healthcare; loans made from careful savers to high-risk borrowers; and the long list of promises made that can’t possibly be kept without jacking up taxes to unprecedented levels.

One of my favorite quotes:

“The only power any government has is the power to crack down on criminals. Well, when there aren’t enough criminals, one makes them. One declares so many things to be a crime that it becomes impossible for men to live without breaking laws.”



The Simpleton has left the building. I won’t be able to update this website until early July, but I’ll be back with a vengeance after that. Please put yourself on my update notification list, and I’ll let you know when something new pops up!